Showing posts with label adoption. Show all posts
Showing posts with label adoption. Show all posts

Sunday, April 15, 2007

ADOPTING ACROSS CULTURES

As I have mentioned before, some adopted children appear to be a different race from their parents. Sensitive parents react to this by helping the child to embrace both her culture of origin and her family's ethnicity.

Since my children are very fair-skinned and German-looking, I assume their genetic sibling(s) will appear to be the natural child(ren) of my embryo recipients. That's why I worry they will not understand that they come from a 6,000-year unbroken line of Jewish ancestors. I think my recipients are wonderful but the only way I could avoid this problem is if my recipients were of Asian or African descent!

" A Chinese Orphan's Journey To a Jewish Rite of Passage

By ANDY NEWMAN; MICHAEL LUO CONTRIBUTED REPORTING.
Published: March 8, 2007

Of the 613 laws in the Torah, the one that appears most often is the directive to welcome strangers. The girl once known as Fu Qian has been thinking about that a lot lately.

Three weeks ago, she stood at the altar of her synagogue on the Upper West Side and gave a speech about it.

Fu Qian, renamed Cecelia Nealon-Shapiro at 3 months, was one of the first Chinese children -- most of them girls -- taken in by American families after China opened its doors to international adoption in the early 1990s. Now, at 13, she is one of the first to complete the rite of passage into Jewish womanhood known as bat mitzvah.

She will not be the last. Across the country, many Jewish girls like her will be studying their Torah portions, struggling to master the plaintive singsong of Hebrew liturgy and trying to decide whether to wear Ann Taylor or a traditional Chinese outfit to the after-party.

There are plenty of American Jews, of course, who do not ''look Jewish.'' And grappling with identity is something all adopted children do, not just Chinese Jews.

But seldom is the juxtaposition of homeland and new home, of faith and background, so stark. And nothing brings out the contrasts like a bat mitzvah, as formal a declaration of identity as any 13-year-old can be called upon to make. The contradictions show up in ways both playful -- yin-and-yang yarmulkes, kiddush cups disguised as papier-mâché dragons, kosher lo mein and veal ribs at the buffet -- and profound.

Yet for Cece, as everyone calls Cecelia, and for many of the girls like her, the odd thing about the whole experience is that it's not much odder than it is for any 13-year-old.

''I knew that when I came to this age I was going to have to do it, so it was sort of natural,'' she said a few days before the ceremony at Congregation Rodeph Sholom, a Reform synagogue on West 83rd Street where she has been a familiar face since her days in the Little Twos program. Besides, she said with a shrug, ''Most of my Chinese friends are Jewish.''

As Zoe Kress, an adoptee in Mt. Laurel, N.J., said about her approaching bat mitzvah: ''Being Chinese and Jewish is normal for me. Thinking about being Chinese and Jewish is a little strange.''

Olivia Rauss, a girl in Massachusetts who celebrated her bat mitzvah last fall on a day when the Jewish harvest festival of Sukkot coincided with the Chinese autumn moon festival, said she saw no tension between the two facets of her identity either.

''Judaism is a religion, Chinese is my heritage and somewhat my culture, and I'm looking at them in a different way,'' she said. ''I don't feel like they conflict with each other at all.''

Cece was born on Jan. 29, 1994, in Jiangxi Province in southeastern China. She was abandoned to an orphanage because of China's one-child rule, and adopted by a lesbian couple, Mary Nealon and Vivian Shapiro. (The couple later adopted another Chinese girl, Gabie, now 5.) Cece has been drawing double-takes for a while, like when she used to ride on Ms. Shapiro's lap on a packed crosstown bus and would burst into the Passover standard ''Dayenu.''

Ms. Shapiro, an advertising buyer, was brought up by atheistic Jews; Ms. Nealon, a school nurse, was raised a Roman Catholic. But after they met, they were drawn to Judaism and decided to give Cece a relatively traditional upbringing.

''That was my hope when I started her in day school,'' Ms. Nealon said, ''that when she got up on the bimah'' -- the lectern where the bat mitzvah girl reads from the Torah -- ''she would feel like she had the right to be there.''

The countdown to the big day was the typical blur of lessons and studying, sit-downs with cantors and tutors, caterers and party planners. There was a thick dossier of Jewish history to master -- history that Cece confessed did not feel like hers. ''I just really try to learn it,'' she said. ''I don't try to think of whose history it is.''

And, of course, there was shopping to be done.

''In my fantasy,'' Ms. Nealon said, ''we'd take her to Chinatown and have this incredibly beautiful Westernized Chinese dress made.''

But Ms. Shapiro said: ''She wanted no part of it. For her, this has nothing to do with being Chinese.'' "

Saturday, February 24, 2007

ONE ADOPTION STORY

My wife's adoption story is an important part of our family history. When her birthmother's boyfriend Tommy returned from Viet Nam, he and Jane rekindled their relationship, discussing marriage. Around this time, Jane found out she was pregnant. Tommy understood that they had not been officially "together" when Jane had the fling with John that resulted in this pregnancy. He still wanted to marry her but he asked her "Don't make me raise another man's baby".

For his part, John was willing to help Jane "take care of" this problem. When he went to his parents to ask for the funds to do this, they said "absolutely not". Abortion was legal by this time, though not in the state where they were living. Still, a young woman in Jane's economic class could easily have accessed a legal or illegal abortion.

John's parents disagreed. They gave Jane the moral and practical support she needed to complete her pregnancy. Adoption in those days was still shrouded in shame so Jane did not have the opportunity to pick the parents herself. But Jane's pastor knew a couple who were eager to have a baby. Jane decided to go through with her pregnancy and in due time give birth to the most wonderful woman ever to grace the planet, my wife Sonia.

We are obviously happy Jane made the difficult choice to bear a child for another couple -- Sonia's parents. We are particularly glad that Jane's consent was an integral part of every aspect of this story. Not all women are so lucky, which is why we strongly believe women should have the choice whether or not to go through with their pregnancies.

Many of my feelings about how destructive lies are in a family are shaped by how Jane chose to handle the information within her own family that she had given birth out of wedlock. Before I go on with this story I ask that you put yourself in Jane's shoes. Jane made the choice to have a baby she knew she could not keep. She dealt with a difficult situation in the way that seemed best. That is her right. We cannot judge her unless we have walked in her shoes. If we can all agree that Jane dealt with her pregnancy and its aftermath in the right way for her I will tell you what that was next time.

Friday, December 8, 2006

WHEN THE ADOPTION'S OVER

As a 40-something member of a commited lesbian relationship my boss (I'll call her L) waited years and was never chosen by a birthmother. As a single woman in her 50's, she had a newborn to adopt within two weeks. This was the bias that informed our choice to donate our embryos only to a lesbian couples. But it was what L did after the adoption was finalized that dictated the contract terms I went on to suggest to our recipients.

In our state there is a two-week wait after the birthmother surrenders the child. During that time, she can change her mind and take the child away from the parent(s) who are adopting. This must be a frightening time for the new parents. In L's case, the worst happened. The birthmother changed her mind and asked for the baby back.

She was a white woman in her 30's who had a fling with a African American man. Her family theatened to disown her if she decided to raise a bi-racial child. She went back and forth on this until the baby was two months old. Understandably this drove L crazy.

The adoption agency stepped in, offering counseling for the birthmother to make a final decision. L agreed to give her on-going updates, photos and eventual visits with the child. With the agreement that this would be an open adoption, the birthmother finally surrendered her maternal rights permanently.

At first, L stuck to the agreement. Then the bio-father called and said "I want to see my child". Him referring to the baby as "his child" angered L so much she cut off all contact between the baby and her genetic parents' families. L got mad and went back on her promises to the birthmother. There was no way for the birthmother to appeal. The adoption was finalized and the open adoption agreement was unenforceable.

I understood L's frustration and fear. And I thought she was looking for, and found, an excuse to betray the birthmother, as she felt the birthmother had betrayed her. What L did was wrong, and it was obviously motivated by insecurity and pettiness.

The person who suffers most in this transaction is the child. Adoptees have the right to know their genetic origins. A loving relationship with the parent(s) can only be enhanced by their decision to allow the adoptee to know their genetic parents. There is a huge body of literature that shows that adoptees who do not know their genetic parents feel incomplete.

Our observation of L's unethical and vindictive behavior informed our search for recipients. Tomorrow, I'll tell you how.

Thursday, December 7, 2006

ADOPTION INFORMS DONATION

In my last job, my supervisor was going through the adoption process. Everything about my embryo donation perspective is informed by my observations of her experience, both the problems she had and the mistakes she made.

In her defense, she had an awful time. She and her partner spent years on a waiting list for a domestic adoption. When they started, they were in their early 40's but they turned 50 without having been selected by a single birthmother.

The adoption agencies had warned them about this. Several agencies refused to even consider them as clients unless they agreed to be listed individually, as single women, not as a lesbian couple. They finally found an agency that allowed them to be listed as a couple. And, as predicted, their application was rejected by every birthmother who saw the photo of the two women togeter.

These women had a lovely home in a good school district. They had been together a long time. One woman was white, the other was bi-racial, and they wanted a child with African American ancestry. The adoption agency assured them that birthmothers would appreciate this. They had good incomes and a lot of love to offer a child. Yet prejudice blocked their hopes for adoption.

Eventually, the stresses around infertility, the failed adoption and different levels of desire to raise children were too much for their relationship and it ended after many years.

Two weeks later my boss, as a single woman, had been picked by a birthmother to receive a newborn. No one had considered a long-term lesbian couple in their 40's, but a single woman in her 50's was picked immediately.

This prejudice cemented our resolve to donate our embryos only to a lesbian couple who would face the same bigotry as potential adopters. But it was what happened after the adoption was finalized that really informed our search for recipients...I'll tell you all about it tomorrow.

Sunday, December 3, 2006

LYING TO THE KIDS

"Donor embryo children 'not told'
By Caroline Ryan
BBC News Online health staff in Berlin

Only a third of couples who conceived their children using donor embryos plan to tell them, research suggests.

Researchers at City University, London, found many of the families they asked feared revealing the information could cause distress within the family.

In contrast, 90% of 30 IVF families and 100% of 28 adoptive families surveyed said they would tell their children about their origins."

There is no rational reason to lie to children about their genetic origins. It can only hurt them when they inevitably find out later. They will already know in their heart that something is wrong in their family. The averted eyes when the child asks a relative "why don't I look like you". The scramble to explain away why a blood type is incompatible. Kids can add, and will eventually wonder how their mother conceived them at age 45 or after a bout with chemotherapy.

We live in an age of genetic testing. It is needlessly traumatic for adoptees or children who came from donor embryos to find out they are not genetically related to their parents on the day they or a relative is diagnosed with a hereditary disease.

What is worse is when the children do not find this out. My ex has a cousin who was adopted at birth. She was never told about the adoption. Growing up a tall, pale, voluptuous woman with straight red hair in a family of short, olive-skinned people with curly black hair she didn't really need to be told she was adopted. It was glaringly obvious to everyone who met her. Yet every time she raised the subject she was told not to be ridiculous, of course she wasn't adopted. This is insanity.

When this woman's mother was hospitalized, and later died, from a serious inherited illness, any parent with an ounce of compassion would have told this girl she would never contract the same disease. But the lies continued.

Not telling the children they were conceived with donor egg or sperm is meant to spare the feelings of one person: the infertile parent. Any child who is the result of a gift of embryos will be proud to know the lengths to which their parents went to bring a baby into their lives. But adults are needlessly ashamed to have fertility problems and want to simply for get about it. They lie to their children because they are too insecure to tell the healing truth.

Prospective parents too ashamed and insecure to raise a child in a home where communication is open and family matters more than genes should rethink becoming parents. Lying to children about something as essential as their genetics serves no one and will ultimately destroy any trust the child has placed in the parent.