As we waited for the embryo donation contract, the recipients kept us up-dated about their lives and we began to share more with them. Jenny's car died and she bought a new one. This was an unwelcome expense as they budgeted for transferring the frozen embryos we were donating to them. At least they hadn't pursued egg donation: with one IVF cycle it would have cost more than their brand new sedan.
Around this time we invited friends and family to celebrate our daughter's first birthday. Jane, my wife Sonia's birthmother, spent six hours on the train to join us for the party. It was the first time we had seen her since our son was born two years earlier.
Since turning 19 and meeting Jane (at, co-incidentally, the same age Jane was when she had given birth to Sonia), Jane and Sonia had seen each other every few years.
Sonia was conceived in the swinging 1960's. At the time, free love was not as big in the South as it was elsewhere. Jane had a steady boyfriend, the first and only man she had ever been with. When he shipped off to fight in Viet Nam they took a break from their relationship.
While visiting a friend, Jane was swept off her feet by John, a handsome fellow student from a nearby college. Good girls don't carry birth control, but as inexperienced as she was, Jane may not have even realized she was rolling the dice.
Tommy was due back from Viet Nam and Jane's period was due, but neither had yet arrived. What happened next would shape many lives.
Showing posts with label birthmothers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label birthmothers. Show all posts
Friday, February 23, 2007
Sunday, December 10, 2006
ANOTHER POINT OF VIEW
When I quit my last job, I took with me a cautionary tale. My ex-supervisor, L, had finally been chosen by a birthmother to receive a newborn, and agreed to an open adoption. She soon used a petty excuse to cruelly cut off contact between her daughter and the daughter's genetic family.
A former co-worker from that workplace and I were talking recently about my own pending embryo donation. I told the co-worker, Barb, how L's awful behavior was informing my own choices in selecting recipients and creating a contract. Did Barb remember the story the same way I did?
At the time, Barb worked more closely with L than I did. She echoed my memory of the story, but added some details. L had complained about the terms of the open adoption from the moment she signed the contract. The birthmother's primary request was for photos and updates of the baby. In the first six months of the baby's life, when a newborn changes so rapidly, L was obligated to send one photo each month.
From Barb's recollection, this requirement did not sit well with L. Barb heard L complain constantly about how inconvenient it was to have to send a photo of the baby every month. She said she did not have time to do this and simply failed to honor the terms of the contract.
This was a shocking revelation. I can only assume that L actually signed the open adoption contract with no intention whatsoever of honoring it. After all, the birthmother gave L the most precious gift one person can give another. L had waited close to a decade for an oportunuty such as this one.
L's behavior sounds particularly lazy to anyone reading this over the internet, but L is not a tech-savvy person. Using a digital camera or sending a photo via email would be completly beyond her. But the least she could have done is buy a disposable camera at the drugstore, snap a shot or two right there showing the baby was still alive, and send it off. She could have even used one of those mail-in photo developing places with the birthmother's address as the return address for the finished photos. Elapsed time: fifteen minutes if she took the baby with her when she bought the camera.
No, it wasn't the photos. L wanted to forget she was infertile. She agreed to an open adoption she didn't want to get a newborn she did want. Then she just refused to honor her side of the agreement. Eventually she did what she wanted to do all along: cut off all contact with the baby's genetic family using the lame excuse that the birthfather contacted her directly to see the baby. I had to consider the possibility that people act like this when I began to investigate donating my embryos to an infertile couple.
NEXT: how L's treachery shaped my search for recipients
A former co-worker from that workplace and I were talking recently about my own pending embryo donation. I told the co-worker, Barb, how L's awful behavior was informing my own choices in selecting recipients and creating a contract. Did Barb remember the story the same way I did?
At the time, Barb worked more closely with L than I did. She echoed my memory of the story, but added some details. L had complained about the terms of the open adoption from the moment she signed the contract. The birthmother's primary request was for photos and updates of the baby. In the first six months of the baby's life, when a newborn changes so rapidly, L was obligated to send one photo each month.
From Barb's recollection, this requirement did not sit well with L. Barb heard L complain constantly about how inconvenient it was to have to send a photo of the baby every month. She said she did not have time to do this and simply failed to honor the terms of the contract.
This was a shocking revelation. I can only assume that L actually signed the open adoption contract with no intention whatsoever of honoring it. After all, the birthmother gave L the most precious gift one person can give another. L had waited close to a decade for an oportunuty such as this one.
L's behavior sounds particularly lazy to anyone reading this over the internet, but L is not a tech-savvy person. Using a digital camera or sending a photo via email would be completly beyond her. But the least she could have done is buy a disposable camera at the drugstore, snap a shot or two right there showing the baby was still alive, and send it off. She could have even used one of those mail-in photo developing places with the birthmother's address as the return address for the finished photos. Elapsed time: fifteen minutes if she took the baby with her when she bought the camera.
No, it wasn't the photos. L wanted to forget she was infertile. She agreed to an open adoption she didn't want to get a newborn she did want. Then she just refused to honor her side of the agreement. Eventually she did what she wanted to do all along: cut off all contact with the baby's genetic family using the lame excuse that the birthfather contacted her directly to see the baby. I had to consider the possibility that people act like this when I began to investigate donating my embryos to an infertile couple.
NEXT: how L's treachery shaped my search for recipients
Labels:
birthfather,
birthmothers,
embryo donation,
open adoption
Friday, December 8, 2006
WHEN THE ADOPTION'S OVER
As a 40-something member of a commited lesbian relationship my boss (I'll call her L) waited years and was never chosen by a birthmother. As a single woman in her 50's, she had a newborn to adopt within two weeks. This was the bias that informed our choice to donate our embryos only to a lesbian couples. But it was what L did after the adoption was finalized that dictated the contract terms I went on to suggest to our recipients.
In our state there is a two-week wait after the birthmother surrenders the child. During that time, she can change her mind and take the child away from the parent(s) who are adopting. This must be a frightening time for the new parents. In L's case, the worst happened. The birthmother changed her mind and asked for the baby back.
She was a white woman in her 30's who had a fling with a African American man. Her family theatened to disown her if she decided to raise a bi-racial child. She went back and forth on this until the baby was two months old. Understandably this drove L crazy.
The adoption agency stepped in, offering counseling for the birthmother to make a final decision. L agreed to give her on-going updates, photos and eventual visits with the child. With the agreement that this would be an open adoption, the birthmother finally surrendered her maternal rights permanently.
At first, L stuck to the agreement. Then the bio-father called and said "I want to see my child". Him referring to the baby as "his child" angered L so much she cut off all contact between the baby and her genetic parents' families. L got mad and went back on her promises to the birthmother. There was no way for the birthmother to appeal. The adoption was finalized and the open adoption agreement was unenforceable.
I understood L's frustration and fear. And I thought she was looking for, and found, an excuse to betray the birthmother, as she felt the birthmother had betrayed her. What L did was wrong, and it was obviously motivated by insecurity and pettiness.
The person who suffers most in this transaction is the child. Adoptees have the right to know their genetic origins. A loving relationship with the parent(s) can only be enhanced by their decision to allow the adoptee to know their genetic parents. There is a huge body of literature that shows that adoptees who do not know their genetic parents feel incomplete.
Our observation of L's unethical and vindictive behavior informed our search for recipients. Tomorrow, I'll tell you how.
In our state there is a two-week wait after the birthmother surrenders the child. During that time, she can change her mind and take the child away from the parent(s) who are adopting. This must be a frightening time for the new parents. In L's case, the worst happened. The birthmother changed her mind and asked for the baby back.
She was a white woman in her 30's who had a fling with a African American man. Her family theatened to disown her if she decided to raise a bi-racial child. She went back and forth on this until the baby was two months old. Understandably this drove L crazy.
The adoption agency stepped in, offering counseling for the birthmother to make a final decision. L agreed to give her on-going updates, photos and eventual visits with the child. With the agreement that this would be an open adoption, the birthmother finally surrendered her maternal rights permanently.
At first, L stuck to the agreement. Then the bio-father called and said "I want to see my child". Him referring to the baby as "his child" angered L so much she cut off all contact between the baby and her genetic parents' families. L got mad and went back on her promises to the birthmother. There was no way for the birthmother to appeal. The adoption was finalized and the open adoption agreement was unenforceable.
I understood L's frustration and fear. And I thought she was looking for, and found, an excuse to betray the birthmother, as she felt the birthmother had betrayed her. What L did was wrong, and it was obviously motivated by insecurity and pettiness.
The person who suffers most in this transaction is the child. Adoptees have the right to know their genetic origins. A loving relationship with the parent(s) can only be enhanced by their decision to allow the adoptee to know their genetic parents. There is a huge body of literature that shows that adoptees who do not know their genetic parents feel incomplete.
Our observation of L's unethical and vindictive behavior informed our search for recipients. Tomorrow, I'll tell you how.
Labels:
adoption,
birthfather,
birthmothers,
open adoption
Thursday, December 7, 2006
ADOPTION INFORMS DONATION
In my last job, my supervisor was going through the adoption process. Everything about my embryo donation perspective is informed by my observations of her experience, both the problems she had and the mistakes she made.
In her defense, she had an awful time. She and her partner spent years on a waiting list for a domestic adoption. When they started, they were in their early 40's but they turned 50 without having been selected by a single birthmother.
The adoption agencies had warned them about this. Several agencies refused to even consider them as clients unless they agreed to be listed individually, as single women, not as a lesbian couple. They finally found an agency that allowed them to be listed as a couple. And, as predicted, their application was rejected by every birthmother who saw the photo of the two women togeter.
These women had a lovely home in a good school district. They had been together a long time. One woman was white, the other was bi-racial, and they wanted a child with African American ancestry. The adoption agency assured them that birthmothers would appreciate this. They had good incomes and a lot of love to offer a child. Yet prejudice blocked their hopes for adoption.
Eventually, the stresses around infertility, the failed adoption and different levels of desire to raise children were too much for their relationship and it ended after many years.
Two weeks later my boss, as a single woman, had been picked by a birthmother to receive a newborn. No one had considered a long-term lesbian couple in their 40's, but a single woman in her 50's was picked immediately.
This prejudice cemented our resolve to donate our embryos only to a lesbian couple who would face the same bigotry as potential adopters. But it was what happened after the adoption was finalized that really informed our search for recipients...I'll tell you all about it tomorrow.
In her defense, she had an awful time. She and her partner spent years on a waiting list for a domestic adoption. When they started, they were in their early 40's but they turned 50 without having been selected by a single birthmother.
The adoption agencies had warned them about this. Several agencies refused to even consider them as clients unless they agreed to be listed individually, as single women, not as a lesbian couple. They finally found an agency that allowed them to be listed as a couple. And, as predicted, their application was rejected by every birthmother who saw the photo of the two women togeter.
These women had a lovely home in a good school district. They had been together a long time. One woman was white, the other was bi-racial, and they wanted a child with African American ancestry. The adoption agency assured them that birthmothers would appreciate this. They had good incomes and a lot of love to offer a child. Yet prejudice blocked their hopes for adoption.
Eventually, the stresses around infertility, the failed adoption and different levels of desire to raise children were too much for their relationship and it ended after many years.
Two weeks later my boss, as a single woman, had been picked by a birthmother to receive a newborn. No one had considered a long-term lesbian couple in their 40's, but a single woman in her 50's was picked immediately.
This prejudice cemented our resolve to donate our embryos only to a lesbian couple who would face the same bigotry as potential adopters. But it was what happened after the adoption was finalized that really informed our search for recipients...I'll tell you all about it tomorrow.
Labels:
adoption,
birthmothers,
discrimination,
lesbian couple
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)